5 Alternatives to the Elgato Stream Deck XL: Better Value, Smaller Setup, and Pro Audio Picks

1) Elgato Stream Deck MK.2 White — If you want the closest match to the Stream Deck XL, this is the easiest swap. You still get the same Elgato software ecosystem, app integrations, and plug-and-play convenience with OBS, Twitch, YouTube, and more. The big difference is size: 15 keys instead of 32, so it’s much more compact and cheaper. What’s better: far lower price, smaller desk footprint, and the same polished workflow. What’s worse: less room for tons of shortcuts, scenes, and folders. Choose this if you like the Elgato experience but don’t need the XL’s extra key count.

2) Elgato Stream Deck MK.2 — This is basically the classic value pick in the Stream Deck range. Compared with the XL, it offers the same 15-key layout and similar performance, but at an even lower price than the white version. What’s better: best balance of price and features, same powerful app control, and a proven streaming tool. What’s worse: still only 15 keys, so power users may hit the limit faster than with the XL. This is the best choice for most streamers, creators, and productivity users who want Stream Deck functionality without paying premium money for 32 buttons.

3) RØDE PodMic — This isn’t a macro controller at all, but it’s a strong alternative if your real bottleneck is stream quality rather than stream control. The PodMic is a broadcast-style dynamic microphone, so it can dramatically improve how you sound on Twitch, YouTube, podcasts, and voiceovers. What’s better: more professional audio, great value for the price, and a rugged build. What’s worse: it won’t trigger scenes, hotkeys, or app actions like the Stream Deck XL. Pick this instead if you already have enough control shortcuts and want to upgrade the part your audience hears first: your voice.

4) Focusrite Scarlett 2i2 Studio 4th Gen — This bundle is a great alternative for creators who want a more complete audio upgrade. It includes an audio interface, microphone, and headphones, making it a much bigger leap for recording and streaming sound than a control pad. What’s better: excellent audio quality, a full starter recording setup, and strong value if you’re building a proper studio. What’s worse: no macro buttons, no scene switching, and more setup complexity than a Stream Deck. Choose this if you’re starting from scratch or want cleaner, more professional audio for content creation.

5) Focusrite Scarlett 18i20 3rd Gen — This is the most advanced option here, but it serves a very different purpose. The 18i20 is for serious recording, production, and multi-input studio work, not quick-stream automation. What’s better: loads of connectivity, high-fidelity sound, and a much more professional audio workflow. What’s worse: it’s expensive, overkill for casual streamers, and doesn’t replace the instant control features of the Stream Deck XL. This is the right pick for musicians, podcasters, and engineers who need a powerful audio hub more than a macro controller.

If you want the same kind of workflow as the Stream Deck XL, stick with the Elgato Stream Deck MK.2 models. If your real goal is better sound, the RØDE and Focusrite options may give you more noticeable results for the money.